To make the best tuna sandwich, you need to start with fresh tuna and the right sauce.
The sauce can make or break a tuna sandwich, so it’s important to choose wisely.
But with so many different sauces out there, it can be tough to know which one to choose.
That’s why I’ve rounded up 11 of the best sauces to put on a tuna sandwich.
Whether you are looking for a mayo-based sauce or something a little lighter, there is sure to be something on this list that you’ll love.
So go ahead and give one (or all!) of these sauces a try the next time you make a tuna sandwich!
What Sauce Goes with Tuna Sandwich?
The best sauces for tuna sandwiches are those that are mayonnaise-based, such as tartar sauce, aioli, and remoulade. These sauces add creaminess and acidity to the sandwich, which helps to balance out the richness of the tuna.
Are you looking for more options?
Then keep scrolling down this page!
Here are 11 sauces that go with tuna sandwiches:
1. Tartar Sauce
I’m sure you’ve had tartar sauce before, but have you ever made it at home?
It’s really easy to do and only requires a few ingredients that you probably already have in your pantry.
Plus, homemade sauces always taste better than store-bought!
This recipe is for a classic tartar sauce made with mayonnaise, diced pickles, diced onions, and lemon juice.
You can also add in some capers or chopped fresh parsley for extra flavor.
This sauce is the perfect addition to any tuna sandwich (or fish sandwich) and will take your lunchtime meal to the next level!
Pro Tip: If you don’t have any pickles on hand, you can use sweet relish instead.
2. Garlic Aioli Sauce
Sometimes the simple things in life are the best, and that’s definitely true when it comes to this garlic aioli sauce.
It’s perfect on a tuna sandwich, but can also be used as a dipping sauce or spread on just about anything.
All you need is some mayonnaise, garlic, and lemon juice.
But trust me, the flavor is out of this world.
Pro Tip: If you want a little extra zing in your aioli, add in a teaspoon or two of Dijon mustard.
3. Remoulade Sauce
This Cajun-Style Remoulade Sauce is a creamy and ultra flavorful sauce that takes minutes to make.
It’s perfect for dipping, as a sandwich spread, or as a sauce for grilled meats or fish.
The sauce is made with mayonnaise, diced dill pickles, diced green onions, Creole mustard, horseradish, paprika, garlic powder, and cayenne pepper.
It’s best if made ahead of time so the flavors have a chance to meld together.
Pro Tip: This sauce is also great on chicken sandwiches, shrimp tacos, or as a dip for veggies!
4. Creamy Garlic Yogurt Sauce
If you have some yogurt in your fridge that’s about to expire, don’t toss it!
Put it to good use in this flavorful and creamy garlic yogurt sauce.
It’s perfect on a tuna sandwich, but would also be delicious on grilled chicken or lamb.
The acidity of the yogurt helps to balance out the richness of the tuna, and the garlic adds a nice depth of flavor.
Pro Tip: Use full-fat yogurt for the best flavor and texture.
5. Olive Tapenade
If you’re feeling a bit fancy and want to take your tuna sandwich up a notch, then I suggest using olive tapenade.
It’s a sauce made from olives, olive oil, and sometimes other ingredients like anchovies, capers, and herbs.
It has a salty, briny flavor that pairs well with fish.
You can find it in the international aisle of most grocery stores.
Pro Tip: If you want to make your own olive tapenade, start by chopping up some pitted olives.
Then add in some olive oil and any other desired ingredients. Season it to taste with salt and pepper.
Give it a good stir and spread it on your sandwich.
6. Basil Pesto
This pesto needs no introduction – it’s a classic for a reason!
I love using it on tuna sandwiches because the flavors go so well together, but it’s also great on chicken, fish, or mixed into pasta.
Pesto is traditionally made with basil, pine nuts, Parmesan cheese, garlic, and olive oil, but there are endless variations out there.
You can use different herbs (like cilantro or mint), swap out the pine nuts for another nut or seed (like pistachios or sunflower seeds), and play around with the cheeses (I like to use feta sometimes).
Pro Tip: If you want to make a quick pesto without having to pull out your food processor, you can make a “pistou” by just mixing chopped fresh herbs (basil is traditional, but feel free to get creative), garlic, Parmesan cheese, and olive oil.
It won’t be as smooth as a traditional pesto, but it’s a delicious shortcut when you’re in a pinch!
If you like Mexican food, then you’ll love this sauce on your tuna sandwich.
It’s a simple salsa made with diced tomatoes, onions, cilantro, and lime juice.
I like to add a little bit of jalapeno for some spice, but you can leave it out if you don’t like things too spicy.
This salsa is so good that I could eat it with a spoon!
Pro Tip: When making the salsa, make sure to taste it and adjust the seasoning as necessary.
You might want to add more lime juice or salt depending on your preferences.
8. BBQ Sauce
BBQ sauce is a favorite in my house, and we use it on everything from chicken to fish.
My kids love it on their sandwiches, and I love how easy it is to make a quick meal with it.
We always have a jar of homemade BBQ sauce in the fridge, and I use it on everything from grilled chicken to roasted vegetables.
9. Jalapeno Hot Sauce
If you prefer your tuna sandwich on the spicier side, then you’ll love this jalapeno hot sauce recipe.
All you need is a can of tuna, some diced jalapenos, and a few other simple ingredients to make a delicious and fiery sandwich filling.
The best part about this sauce is that it’s low in calories and fat, so you can enjoy your sandwich without guilt.
Pro Tip: If you don’t have any fresh jalapenos on hand, you can substitute canned diced green chilies.
10. Honey Mustard Sauce
Here’s a family-friendly option for those who want to enjoy a delicious tuna sandwich without all the fuss.
This recipe uses a simple honey mustard sauce that can be made in minutes using common pantry staples.
The sauce is perfect for those who like their tuna sandwiches on the sweeter side.
It’s also great for those who are looking for an alternative to mayo-based sauces.
Pro Tip: If you’re not a fan of honey, you can substitute with agave nectar or maple syrup.
11. Buffalo Sauce
This sauce is a bolder and fancier version of a hot sauce easily made with common ingredients.
It can be used as a sandwich spread, dip, or dressing, and only takes a few minutes to make.
The key to this sauce is to balance the acidity of the vinegar with the sweetness of the honey so it’s not too vinegary or too sweet.
I also like to add a little bit of smoked paprika for some depth of flavor.
Pro Tip: This sauce is also great on chicken!
What Sauce Goes with Tuna Sandwich? (11 Best Sauces)
- Tartar Sauce
- Garlic Aioli Sauce
- Remoulade Sauce
- Creamy Garlic Yogurt Sauce
- Olive Tapenade
- Basil Pesto
- BBQ Sauce
- Jalapeno Hot Sauce
- Honey Mustard Sauce
- Buffalo Sauce
- Pick your favorite sauce from this list to add to your tuna sandwich recipe.
- Prepare the ingredients according to the recipe.
- Enjoy in no time!