What Cheese Goes with Sloppy Joes? (10 Delicious Cheeses)

Knowing what cheese goes with sloppy joes can take your meal to the next level!

When you combine juicy beef, sweet-and-tangy sauce, and melted cheese, you get a complete home run of comfort food.

It’s the ultimate quick-fix meal that anyone in the family can enjoy.

But don’t settle for any ol’ slice of cheese on your sloppy joe.

Here are 10 tasty cheeses that will give your sandwich an extra boost of flavor and creamy texture characteristic of all great cheesy dishes.

You’ll find classics like cheddar and pepperjack mixed in with some more unique choices such as gouda and provolone.

There’s something for everyone no matter their tastes or preferences!

In a rush? Here is the short answer:

When selecting a cheese to go with sloppy joes, cheddar is the classic choice. However, you can also try mozzarella for a milder flavor or pepper jack for some added heat. Swiss cheese can also be used as an alternative that adds nutty and creamy notes.

Let’s take a look at all of the cheeses!

cheeses to pair with Sloppy Joes

1. Cheddar

Cheddar Cheese

One of the most popular cheeses in the world, cheddar has a buttery and moist texture with a slightly melty consistency.

Aged cheddars become more nutty, crumbly, and sharp with a slightly tangier finish and some earthy notes.

It’s truly a versatile crowd-pleaser that can be used in many different dishes or enjoyed on its own.

When using cheddar as an ingredient for your sloppy joes, it adds creaminess to the dish while also enhancing the flavor profile by bringing out its nutty and salty qualities.

You can either crumble it over your sloppy joes before serving or melt it into them for an extra cheesy kick!

Other ways to use this cheese include shredding it over salads, adding it to macaroni and cheese recipes, topping grilled vegetables with melted slices of cheddar, or baking up some delicious cheesy biscuits.

2. Pepperjack

Pepper Jack Cheese

If you prefer a bit of heat with your cheese, then pepper jack is the perfect one for you!

It has a mild spiciness that comes from the sweet peppers, rosemary, habañero chilies, garlic and jalapeños.

The texture of this cheese is semi-soft and open which makes it easy to melt.

Pepperjack can be used in many different recipes such as tacos, nachos, sandwiches, and more. But one of my favorite ways to use this delicious cheese is with sloppy joes!

It adds so much flavor to the dish and helps to make them even more delicious.

  1. To make your own pepper jack sloppy joe recipe simply add some ground beef or turkey into a skillet on medium heat until cooked thoroughly.
  2. Then add in diced bell peppers and onions along with tomato sauce before stirring in shredded pepper jack cheese until melted together nicely.
  3. Serve on buns or over mashed potatoes for an extra tasty dinner!
See also  What Sauce Goes with Bacon Wrapped Shrimp? (13 Sauces)

3. Mozzarella

Fresh Mozzarella
Source: seriouseats.com

Not too strong and not too mild, Mozzarella cheese is a classic choice when it comes to cheesy dishes.

It has a mild flavor with hints of cream, saltiness and slight tang.

This makes it perfect for adding creamy texture and rich taste to dishes such as macaroni and cheese, lasagna, or pizza.

When making sloppy joes you can use Mozzarella to make them even more delicious.

For example, you could top the sloppy joes with shredded mozzarella before putting them in the oven until melted; this will add a nice gooey texture that pairs perfectly with the juicy filling.

You could also mix some finely grated mozzarella into the beef mixture before cooking it – this will give your sloppy joes an extra layer of flavor that everyone will love!

4. Gouda


Classics never go out of style, especially when it comes to Gouda cheese.

Gouda is a Dutch cow’s milk cheese that boasts a nutty-sweet flavor, making it an excellent choice for many dishes.

Whether you opt for young or aged gouda, you’ll be sure to find something delicious!

Gouda pairs well with sloppy joes as the sweetness and creaminess of the cheese help balance out the spiciness of ground beef.

You can top your sloppy joe with slices or shreds of gouda, melt some on top just before serving, add small cubes into the mix itself for added texture and flavor, or even use it as a binder in place of breadcrumbs.

5. Emmentaler

Emmentaler Cheese

Easy to work with, Emmentaler cheese is a popular Swiss cheese that has a mild taste and fruitier aroma.

It also has a thin rind which helps to make it easier to cut and grate for recipes.

When used in cooking, Emmentaler adds an interesting depth of flavor that can be enhanced when melted or fried.

Its slightly nutty sweetness pairs well with meats such as ham and bacon, making it the perfect addition to sloppy joes.

You can also use it in a quiche or on top of pizza for added flavor and texture.

In addition to adding great flavor, this cheese works well as a topping for many dishes due to its melting qualities.

See also  What Cheese Goes with Spinach Salad?

Try grating some over salads or tacos for extra crunch and complexity!

6. Provolone


I can’t get enough of this cheese – the complex and buttery flavor of provolone makes it a great addition to many recipes.

It pairs well with sloppy joes, as it adds more depth to the flavors in the dish.

You can use thinly sliced provolone in place of buns for your sloppy joes, or you could make a grilled cheese sandwich with slices of provolone and a generous helping of sloppy joe filling inside.

You could also melt some shredded provolone on top before serving – delicious!

If you want something even richer, try adding some cubes of smoked gouda or cheddar for an extra kick.

Or mix it up by using different types of cheese like mozzarella and feta – there are so many ways to enjoy this amazing cheese!

7. Monterey Jack

Monterey Jack

You can’t deny that Monterey Jack cheese is a delicious and versatile cheese.

It has a mild, buttery flavor and slightly sweet taste that makes it perfect for adding to sandwiches, tacos, quesadillas, and other Mexican dishes.

Monterey Jack cheese pairs very well with sloppy joes because of its creamy texture.

You can use it in place of cheddar or American cheese on top of the sloppy joe mix before you serve it.

Or you could even stir some shredded Monterey Jack into the sloppy joe mixture itself for an extra creamy layer of flavor!

You can also use Monterey Jack as part of a cheesy topping for your sloppy joes – just add some Parmesan, mozzarella, or cheddar along with the Monterey Jack for an added depth of flavor.

This combination will make your sloppy joes even more delicious!

8. Colby


Similar to cheddar, Colby cheese has a mild flavor with just the right amount of sharpness.

It is creamy and melts easily, making it an ideal choice for grilled sandwiches or melted over burgers.

Its subtle flavor adds complexity to any dish while still allowing other flavors to shine through.

Colby cheese is perfect for adding that extra something special when making sloppy joes.

Try adding it as part of the mix between the meat and sauce as well as topping off your sandwich before you serve it!

You’ll get a great combination of sweet and savory all in one bite.

Additionally, you can use shredded Colby on top of your sloppy joe before serving; this will give your sandwich a crunchy texture and nutty flavor that will take it up another level!

9. Havarti


This subtly sweet and acidic cheese is Havarti, a semi-hard cheese with a springy texture.

See also  12 Easy Sauces that Go with Jerk Chicken

It has rich buttery notes that are perfect for melting over burgers or sandwiches.

Havarti pairs especially well with sloppy joes; you can use it to top the sandwich, melt it in between two slices of bread for an extra cheesy twist, or even mix some into the sauce itself for more flavor.

You could also grate it over the sloppy joe mixture to make an easy crunchy topping.

For something a little different, try crumbling Havarti over a salad or using it as an ingredient in macaroni and cheese—it’s sure to add some delicious depth of flavor!

10. Gruyère


Of course, I had to include Gruyère in this list!

This cheese is known for its rich, creamy, salty, and nutty flavor.

However, its flavor does vary depending on age; young Gruyère has pronounced creaminess and nuttiness while older Gruyère has developed an earthier taste that’s a bit more complex.

Gruyère can be used in many dishes like fondue or macaroni and cheese but it also goes well with sloppy joes.

To incorporate the cheese into your sloppy joe mix simply grate it over the top of your meat mixture as it simmers together or sprinkle some over each sandwich before serving.

You can also try adding grated Gruyère to your sloppy joe sauce to give it a richer flavor.

With any of these methods, you will get delicious cheesy goodness in every bite!


What Cheese Goes with Sloppy Joes?

When you're aware of what cheese goes with sloppy joes, you can take your meal to the next level! In this article, I'm sharing 10 different kinds of cheese that are perfect for adding to your sloppy joe mix. I'll provide a brief overview of each one, along with some tips for how to use them for maximum flavor. Whether you like your sloppy joes extra cheesy, or just want to add a hint of flavor, you'll find something here that will make your next meal extra delicious!
Prep Time 3 minutes
Cook Time 3 minutes
Total Time 6 minutes
Course Cheese
Cuisine American
Servings 4 people
Calories 451 kcal


  • Cheddar
  • Pepperjack
  • Mozzarella
  • Gouda
  • Emmentaler
  • Provolone
  • Monterey Jack
  • Colby
  • Havarti
  • Gruyère


  • Choose your favorite cheese from this collection to add to your sloppy joe.
  • Prepare the rest of your meal.
  • Enjoy in no time!