What Sauce Goes with Chicken Pot Pie? (29 Sauces)

If you’re a fan of chicken pot pie, then you know what a blessing it is to have a delicious sauce to go with it.

The sauce can make or break a dish—it’s what makes it feel like comfort food and not just something you have on your plate every night because it’s easy to make.

And if you’re looking for that perfect sauce for your chicken pot pie, we’ve got 29 sauces for you to try!

What Sauce Goes with Chicken Pot Pie

Why Consider Serving a Sauce with Chicken Pot Pie?

Chicken Pot Pie

Chicken pot pie is a classic dish—but it can be lacking in the sauce department.

What’s more, making a sauce on the side to go with your chicken pot pie is a great way to add an extra level of flavor and complexity to this comfort food classic.

Here are two reasons why you should consider serving a sauce with chicken pot pie:

  • It’s not just about the chicken! Chicken pot pie has a lot of chicken in it, but it also has vegetables (See Also: What Vegetables Go in Chicken Pot Pie), so it’s important to have something that can complement those flavors. The right sauce will help bring out what makes your chicken pot pie great—and give you some options for how you want to eat it!
  • A delicious sauce can make your meal even better! You don’t have to eat your chicken pot pie with just one type of sauce; try different ones until you find your favorite combination!

What Sauce Goes with Chicken Pot Pie?

There are many sauces that go well with chicken pot pie. A white sauce made with milk, flour, and butter is a classic choice. You could also go for a creamier sauce by adding some cream cheese to the mix. Or, if you’re looking for something with a bit more of a kick, you can try a gravy made with chicken broth, Worcestershire sauce, and dry mustard.


Keep scrolling for more ideas!

1. Bernaise Sauce

Bernaise Sauce
Source: www.recipetineats.com

First up is Bernaise Sauce.

It’s a classic French sauce that’s made with egg yolks, vinegar, shallots and butter.

The main ingredients are butter and egg yolk so it’s very rich and creamy.

But it also has the tartness of vinegar which cuts the richness perfectly.

2. Blackberry Sauce

Blackberry sauce
Source: cookingwithcarlee.com

Next up is Blackberry Sauce.

This sauce gets its tartness from blackberries and its sweetness from honey so it’s a nearly perfect pairing for chicken pot pie.

It’s thick enough to coat a spoon but not so thick that it’ll overpower the dish itself—it just really brings out the flavors in the pie without knocking them over.

3. Blue Cheese Sauce

Blue Cheese Sauce
Source: www.simplyrecipes.com

Next there is Blue Cheese Sauce which adds a little bit of savory saltiness to your meal without being too heavy on any one flavor or texture: there won’t be too much sweetness from the berries or creaminess from the buttery sauce (or anything else for that matter!).

This will just add something extra delicious to your pie without distracting from its original flavor profile!

See also  What Cheese Goes with Beets? (10 Delicious Cheeses)

4. Brown Butter Sauce

Brown Butter Sauce
Source: www.simplyrecipes.com

Brown butter is a delicious sauce, and it goes well with chicken pot pie because it’s so rich and savory.

It’s made by cooking butter over medium-high heat until it browns and smells amazing, which gives it a nutty flavor that’s just perfect for chicken pot pie.

5. Buffalo Sauce

Buffalo Sauce
Source: therecipecritic.com

Buffalo sauce is a spicy sauce usually made from hot sauce, butter, and vinegar.

Because of its strong flavor, buffalo sauce can overpower some dishes—but not chicken pot pie!

The tanginess of the vinegar will cut through the richness of the cream in your chicken pot pie just right, making sure that your meal doesn’t get too heavy or overbearingly creamy.

6. Chimichurri Sauce

Chimichurri Sauce
Source: www.bonappetit.com

Chimichurri sauce is a bright green sauce made with fresh herbs, olive oil, and garlic.

It’s often served with grilled meats and vegetables.

This sauce is especially good with chicken pot pie because it adds a fresh, bright flavor that pairs nicely with the creamy filling of the pie.

7. Cilantro Pesto Sauce

Cilantro Pesto Sauce
Source: www.simplywhisked.com

Cilantro pesto is similar to traditional pesto except that it uses cilantro instead of basil.

The result is a sauce with an earthy flavor that pairs well with chicken pot pie’s hearty filling.

It also adds a bit of spice (See Also: What Spices Go in Chicken Pot Pie) from the crushed red pepper flakes!

8. Creamy Dill Sauce

Creamy Dill Sauce
Source: www.recipetineats.com

A creamy dill sauce is just what you need if you’re looking for something smooth and flavorful for your chicken pot pie!

This sauce has a hint of tartness from the lemon juice and sweetness from the honey, but it still has enough saltiness to balance out all of those flavors well together.

The added dill brings out all the best qualities in this dish while still letting them shine through individually too!

9. Creamy Red Pepper Sauce

Creamy Red Pepper Sauce
Source: skinnyfitalicious.com

A creamy red pepper sauce is a perfect complement to this pie, especially when the filling is chock-full of vegetables.

The creaminess of the sauce helps to balance out the hearty, rustic nature of the filling, and it also helps to cut through some of the richness that you might find in a chicken pot pie.

This sauce pairs nicely with mushrooms and peas—both of which are often found in chicken pot pies.

10. Enchilada Sauce

Enchilada Sauce
Source: cookieandkate.com

Enchilada sauce is great for those who want a slightly spicy sauce for their pie.

This sauce is made with tomatoes, onion, garlic, cumin, oregano, chili powder and salt.

You can make this sauce yourself or buy it ready-made at most grocery stores.

11. Green Goddess Sauce

Green Goddess Dressing
Source: www.loveandlemons.com

This sauce has an interesting flavor that pairs well with your pie because of its tangy taste and bright green color!

It’s made from mayonnaise, sour cream, anchovies and chives.

The herbs add a freshness to the dish while the mayonnaise keeps it creamy enough to enjoy on its own or over top of some crusty bread slices!

12. Harissa Sauce

Harissa Sauce
Source: www.themediterraneandish.com

Harissa is a spicy sauce made from chili peppers, garlic, and olive oil.

It’s used in many Mediterranean dishes, as well as Middle Eastern cuisine.

It’s great on chicken pot pie because it adds an extra kick of heat to the dish, while also adding some sweetness from the garlic and acidity from the lemon juice.

13. Honey Mustard Sauce

Honey Mustard Sauce
Source: www.budgetbytes.com

Honey mustard is one of those sauces that’s just good on everything—it works with any type of meat or vegetable, and you can make it as sweet or spicy as you want by adjusting your ingredients.

See also  5 Best Dressings for Egg Salad: Elevate Your Lunch Game

We love pairing honey mustard with this pie because it balances out the richness of the dish with a bit more sweetness and tanginess than other sauces would give it.

14. Lemon Dill Sauce

Lemon Dill Sauce
Source: addapinch.com

Lemon dill is another sauce that can add sweetness or spice depending on how much sugar you add (or leave out).

For this pie, we like to use lemon dill because it brings both brightness and creaminess to the dish—and who doesn’t love a little bit of brightness?

15. Marinara Sauce

Marinara Sauce
Source: cookieandkate.com

Marinara sauce is a mix of tomatoes, garlic and basil that makes any dish it is added to taste amazing.

Chicken pot pie is no exception.

Marinara sauce goes well with chicken pot pie because it adds a sweet flavor to the pie that complements the savory taste of the chicken.

16. Sriracha Sauce

Sriracha Sauce
Source: AllRecipes.com

Sriracha sauce is made from red jalapeños with garlic and vinegar added to it.

It has a spicy flavor that can be toned down by adding more vinegar or sugar.

Chicken pot pie pairs well with this sauce because of its spicy nature and because it can be used in moderation to add just enough heat without overpowering the other flavors in your meal.

17. Tomato Sauce

Tomato Sauce
Source: www.simplyrecipes.com

Tomato sauce is an Italian staple made from tomatoes, garlic, onions and spices such as basil and oregano which give it an earthy flavor that goes well with any meat dish including this pie.

Tomato sauce goes well with chicken pot pie because it adds a sweet flavor without overpowering other ingredients in your meal like some other sauces might do if added too liberally (e.g., ketchup).

18. BBQ Sauce

BBQ Sauce
Source: addapinch.com

It’s easy to go overboard with BBQ sauce, but it’s also one of the best ways to give your chicken pot pie a rich, deep flavor that will make your mouth sing.

BBQ sauce is also great because it comes in so many different varieties—you can choose between sweet or spicy, mild or hot, and even tomato-based or vinegar-based.

You can even get creative and make your own sauce at home!

19. Tzatziki Sauce

Tzatziki Sauce
Source: www.loveandlemons.com

If you’re looking for something cool and creamy to complement your chicken pot pie, tzatziki sauce is perfect.

It’s made from yogurt, cucumbers, garlic and dill—all ingredients that go great with chicken pot pie!

It will keep your mouth watering as you wait for the main event!

20. Aioli

Source: cookieandkate.com

Aioli is a delicious French sauce made from mayonnaise (or any other kind of oil) mixed with garlic and other herbs like parsley or chives.

It has a thick consistency that will add richness to any dish without making it too heavy, which makes it perfect for pairing with chicken pot pie!

21. Salsa

Source: www.cookingclassy.com

Salsa is a great sauce for chicken pot pie because it’s tangy and spicy, which helps cut through the richness of the pastry crust and filling.

Plus, it’s easy to make!

  1. Just add chopped tomato, onion, and cilantro to a bowl with some lime juice, salt, and pepper.
  2. If you’re feeling ambitious, add some jalapeños or chili powder for an extra kick.

22. Vinaigrette

A Simple Vinaigrette
Source: cookieandkate.com

Vinaigrette is another great sauce that pairs well with chicken pot pie because it has a light flavor profile—it won’t overpower the other ingredients or make your mouth feel like you’re eating something too heavy or rich.

  1. To make vinaigrette, mix together olive oil, vinegar (your choice), salt, pepper, and any herbs or spices you like (fresh parsley is always nice).
  2. Then drizzle it over your pot pie before serving!

23. Hot Sauce

Hot Sauce
Source: wholefully.com

Hot sauce is perfect if you want something spicy but don’t want to make homemade salsa or vinaigrette!

See also  The Best Cheese for Elk Burgers (+10 Alternatives)

Just add some hot sauce to your chicken pot pie after baking it so that the heat permeates through every bite of this comfort food classic!

24. Soy Sauce

Soy Sauce
Source: thethingswellmake.com

Soy sauce is a great option to go with chicken pot pie because it adds a salty flavor, which pairs well with the other flavors in the dish.

It also brings an umami flavor that can help highlight other ingredients in the dish, such as chicken or vegetables.

25. Fish Sauce

Fish Sauce
Source: www.hungryhuy.com

Fish sauce adds a strong taste to chicken pot pie that is similar to soy sauce but with slightly more complex flavors and aromas.

You can also use fish sauce as an ingredient in your own sauces or recipes if you don’t want to add too much sodium or additional ingredients to your dish.

26. Worcestershire Sauce

Worcestershire Sauce
Source: Food.com

Worcestershire sauce is another option for creating a slightly sour taste that goes well with many different types of food, including chicken pot pie—especially when combined with other sauces like soy and fish sauce!

27. Tartar Sauce

Tartar Sauce
Source: www.inspiredtaste.net

Tartar sauce is a classic accompaniment to fried fish and chips (See Also: What Salad Goes With Fish and Chips? 15 Best Salads), but it also goes great with chicken pot pie.

The tangy, creamy sauce adds a nice contrast to the earthy vegetables in the pie.

It also adds a bit of spice that helps cut through the richness of the baked pastry crust.

28. Cheese Sauce

Cheese Sauce
Source: bakingmischief.com

Cheese sauce is one of the most versatile sauces around—it can be used as an appetizer dip, as a topping for baked potatoes, or even as an ingredient in casseroles and soups.

It’s also perfect for pairing with chicken pot pie because it adds richness and creaminess without being too heavy on its own.

You can even make your own cheese sauce at home with just three ingredients (cheese, butter and flour).

29. White Sauce

White Sauce
Source: www.bettycrocker.com

White sauce is made from milk (or another dairy product), butter and flour—and you can use it to top everything from mashed potatoes to macaroni and cheese!

White sauces often have a richer texture than other types of sauces because there’s no tomato paste involved like in red sauce recipes—so it works well with chicken pot pie because white sauce tends not to overpower other flavors while still adding plenty of deliciousness!

chicken pot pie

What Sauce Goes with Chicken Pot Pie? (29 Sauces)

Making a chicken pot pie is a lot of work, so you want to make sure that the sauce you serve with it is the best possible option.
There are several factors to consider when choosing the right sauce for your chicken pot pie. First and foremost, you want to pick a sauce that will complement the flavors of your chicken and vegetables. If your vegetables are very sweet, for example, then it might be better to choose an acidic or spicy sauce to balance them out.
Another factor is texture: if you’re making a white sauce for your chicken pot pie, then it should be thick enough not to run off your fork when you try to eat it but thin enough that it doesn’t leave large clumps behind in each bite. Finally, always remember that a good sauce should be made with fresh ingredients instead of canned ones!
Prep Time 5 minutes
Cook Time 5 minutes
Total Time 10 minutes
Course Sauce
Cuisine American
Servings 4 people
Calories 388 kcal


  • Bernaise Sauce
  • Blackberry Sauce
  • Blue Cheese Sauce
  • Brown Butter Sauce
  • Buffalo Sauce
  • Chimichurri Sauce
  • Cilantro Pesto Sauce
  • Creamy Dill Sauce
  • Creamy Red Pepper Sauce
  • Enchilada Sauce
  • Green Goddess Sauce
  • Harissa Sauce
  • Honey Mustard Sauce
  • Lemon Dill Sauce
  • Marinara Sauce
  • Sriracha Sauce
  • Tomato Sauce
  • BBQ Sauce
  • Tzatziki Sauce
  • Aioli
  • Salsa
  • Vinaigrette
  • Hot Sauce
  • Soy Sauce
  • Fish Sauce
  • Worcestershire Sauce
  • Tartar Sauce
  • Cheese Sauce
  • White Sauce


  • Pick your favorite sauce from this list to serve with your pie.
  • Prepare the ingredients according to the recipe.
  • Enjoy in no time!
Keyword What Sauce Goes with Chicken Pot Pie